1. Pentair 011018 IntelliFlo
Check Price at Amazon
Pentair 011018 IntelliFlo
Specifications
- Pool type: In-Ground
- Amperage: 16 amps
- Horsepower: 3hp
- Union connection: 2 x 2 inches
- Speed settings: 8 programmable speed settings
- Speed range: 450-3450 rpm
- TEFC Permanent Motor : Yes
- Warranty: 2-year
- Main highlights: Built-in timer, built-in diagnostics, pump control panel alarm LED/error messages
After reviewing more than 10 models, we consider that the Pentair 011018 IntelliFlo represents the highest quality model that you can buy. In fact, it is the best variable speed pump for horsepower. With a 3hp powerful motor and a plethora of features, this model tends to be one of the most sought-after models. It comes equipped with 8 programmable speed settings and a built-in digital timer that ensure a good operation. Plus, it has many other benefits that will surely raise your interest.
Firstly, you should know that it helps you save up to 90% on electrical bills. According to some comparison tables, you could save up the estimated $1500 each year. More than that, the built-in diagnostics of the pump have the role to protect it for longer service life. What we really like about this pump is the fact that it comes with a TEFC permanent magnet motor. Thanks to this totally enclosed fan-cooled motor, the pump is one of the silent pumps available in the current market. As in hybrid cars, this motor reduces noise and vibration.
PROS
- Pump control panel alarm LED and error messages
- 8 programmable speeds
- Built-in diagnostic feature
- The quietest pump ever
- It improves filter performance
- Energy star certified
CONS
- The directions for programming the pump can be confusing
Verdict
The Pentair 011018 IntelliFlo is the best option out there. Based on customers opinions, it is the best pump for horsepower. Based on our reviews, it is the quietest model ever. It is Energy Star certified, NSF certified and UL-C US certified as well. Thanks to this pump, you will be able to save up to 90% on electrical bills.
2. Hayward SP3400VSP Ecostar
Check Price at Amazon
Hayward SP3400VSP Ecostar
Specifications
- Pool type: In-Ground
- Amperage: 10.9 amps
- Horsepower: 3hp
- Union connection: 2 x 2 – ½ inches
- Speed settings: 8 custom speeds
- Speed range: 600-3450 rpm
- TEFC Permanent Motor : Yes
- Warranty: 1-year
- Main highlights: Auto-priming capacity, Extra leaf-holding capacity basket, easy to use digital control interface, No-rib, XL. basket design
Our second option is a poop pump that comes with many interesting features. This Energy star certified pump comes with a very easy to use digital display that even allows you to change its settings according to your preferences. It features a permanent magnet, totally enclosed fan cooled motor thanks to which it is quieter and much more efficient. What we really like about this model is the fact that it is fully programmable. It has a touchpad control that can easily be rotated to 4 different positions for better access. In simple terms, it allows you to access the pump in tight spaces. Due to the onboard diagnostics, it acts as an automatic protection against temperature extremes, priming failures as well as voltage fluctuations.
The main role of this pump is to maintain the water in your swimming pool clean and clear. As compared to other pumps, it has a no-rib basket that ensures easy debris removal. According to the manufacturer’s specifications, this pool pump will help you save up to 75% on energy costs. Overall, this is an in-ground pool pump with variable speed and quiet operation that will surely meet your requirements.
PROS
- It comes with an intuitive digital control interface
- 8 custom speeds
- Quiet operation
- Permanent magnet, totally enclosed fan cooled (TEFC) motor
- It comes with an extra large basket
CONS
- It is a bit difficult to install
Verdict
In terms of efficiency and reliability, the SP3400VSP Ecostar by Hayward could be exactly what you need. It comes with a touchpad control, a large basket and an automatic protection against failures and temperature extremes. It is a nice way to keep your pool clean and safe to use.
3. Hayward SP2303VSP Max-Flo
Check Price at Amazon
Hayward SP2303VSP Max-Flo
Specifications
- Pool type: In-Ground
- Amperage: 0.4 – 10 amps
- Horsepower: 1.65 hp
- Union connection: 1.5 x 2 inches
- Speed settings: 8 custom speeds
- Speed range: 600-3450 rpm
- TEFC Permanent Motor : Yes
- Warranty: 1-year
- Main highlights: Self-contained 24-hour clock, Built-in protection
Based on market popularity and available features, we are proud to include on our list a very efficient pool pump: Hayward SP2303VSP Max-Flo. This Energy Star certified pump which is fairly quiet in operation comes with many impressive updates and it works much better than its previous version. Like the previous models, it also comes equipped with a permanent magnet, totally enclosed fan cooled TEFC motor that provides great energy efficient and thanks to which it can be considered among the most reliable pumps available in the current market.
If you are thinking about purchasing this model, it is important to know that it is available in two versions, such as 115V and 230V and can be installed whether in stand-alone mode with Hayward automation or with competitive control systems via remote control. The fact that it has a fully programmable digital control interface is a major perk as it can be rotated to 4 different positions for better access and more convenient viewing. Also, it should be noted that it is Energy Star certified and eligible for residential use.
PROS
- It is known as one of the most efficient pumps on the market
- Quiet operation thanks to its permanent magnet motor
- Easy to install
- It helps you save up to 80% on energy bills
- Affordable than other models
CONS
- The digital computer can develop faults over time
Verdict
Another energy efficient pump that will save you a lot of money on energy bills is the SP2303VSP MaxFlo VS model by Hayward. It is a powerful pump with a TEFC motor thanks to which is has a fairly quiet operation. In spite of its drawbacks, it still is one of the most appreciated variable speed pump on the market, these days.
4. Pentair 342001 SuperFlo
Check Price at Amazon
Specifications
- Pool type: In-Ground
- Amperage: 10.9 amps
- Horsepower: 1 1/2 hp
- Union connection: Not given information
- Speed settings: 4 speeds
- Speed range: 600-3450 rpm
- TEFC Permanent Motor : Yes
- Warranty: 2-year
- Main highlights: Built-in timer, real-time 24-hour clock
You will be surprised to discover how efficient our 4th model is. The Pentair 342001 SuperFlo is a pump with variable-speed that delivers impressive electricity helping you increase your monthly savings by up to 80%. The 342001 Superflo is designed for standard pools in need of a 1.5hp pump. Like its competitors, it comes with a lot of features. Of these, we would like to mention about the real-time clock with 24-hour memory retention and its simple user interface which is extremely easy to set and operate. In addition to this, it comes with three programmable speed settings and an override speed setting.
The speed range of this pump varies between 600 and 3450 rpm. It is a single phase model with a full-rated operation. It is also worth mentioning that it comes equipped with a TEFC motor. Thanks to this, there is less noise and vibration. Like its competitors, it is eco-friendly and energy efficient. So, if you are thinking about purchasing a poop pump that will help you save money on energy costs, this could be a great option.
PROS
- Clock with memory retention of 24 hours
- Three operating speed settings
- ser interface – very easy to use
- TEFC motor
- Energy-efficient
Verdict
The 342001 SuperFlo VS is an energy efficient variable speed pump that comes with a powerful TEFC motor and three operating speed settings. It is very easy to install and extremely easy to operate. In spite of its ultra-quiet TEFC motor, it tends to be a bit noisy. However, considering its affordable price, it is a good option to consider when making a purchase.
Check Price at Amazon
Specifications
- Pool type: In-Ground
- Amperage: 5.9 amps
- Horsepower: 1.5 hp
- Union connection: 1.5 inches
- Speed settings: 4 speeds
- Speed range: 600-3000 rpm
- TEFC Permanent Motor : Yes
- Warranty: 1-year
- Main highlights: Digital control interface, programmable timers
If you are interested in purchasing a variable speed pump for your swimming pool but you are on a limited budget, this might be exactly what you need. In terms of reliability and performance, this is one of the best models. As compared to single or double speed pumps, this is incredibly quiet. Also, it is incredibly efficient thanks to its totally enclosed fan cooled motor. What we really like about this pump is the fact that it comes with a fully programmable, touchpad control that can be rotated to 4 different positions for more access. This makes it fit in tight corners and spaces, so you won’t be forced to install it in a place that you don’t like. The SP2610X152S pump is available in both 115V and 230V versions.
It has an universal compatibility which means that it can operate independently or it can operate with competitive systems via relay control. Overall, this is a good option as it gives you the possibility to match the speed of your pool pump according to your preferences.
PROS
- It comes with a powerful TEFC motor
- Thanks to its digital control interface it can rotate to 4 different positions
- Energy Star certified
- Eco-friendly
- Easy to install
Verdict
Easy to install and operate, this variable speed pump could be a great addition to your swimming pool. It is affordable and comes with a lot of features. Although it is not as powerful as its competitors, it still is a good option to consider.
Check Price at Amazon
Specifications
- Pool type: In / Above Ground
- Amperage: 15 amps
- Horsepower: 1.5 hp
- Union connection: 1.5 inches
- Speed settings: 4 speeds
- Speed range: 750 to 3450 rpm
- TEFC Permanent Motor : Yes
- Warranty: 1-year
- Main highlights: LCD screen display LCD screen display, self-contained 24-hour time clock, built-in timer
Looking for a pool pump with variable speed settings that can pump the pool water quicker or slower? If so, the 75021 model by STKUSA could be a great choice. The pump comes with a powerful 1.5 hp motor. It has an easy to use control panel that allows you to schedule the speed according to your preferences. What we really like about this pump is the fact that it has a quiet operation. However, you can set its operating time. It can work when you are not home.
The pump delivers 750 to 3450 rpm and has a frequency of 50 Hz/60Hz. It is an energy-saving model that will help you save a lot of money on energy bills. It works great with both in-ground and above ground pools. Plus, it is compatible with various filters including DE, sand and cartridge filter. Compared to other similar models, the pump comes with a high price, so if you are on a limited budget, then you should probably have a look at its above competitors.
PROS
- Compatible with multiple filters, such as DE, sand and cartridge filter
- 4 speed settings
- Eco-friendly
Verdict
We are pleasantly surprised to discover that this pump by STKUSA comes with a variable speed 1.5hp motor that delivers 750 to 3450 rpm. It is quiet and works great with both in-ground and above ground swimming pools. It has an easy to read and operate control panel thanks to which you can save a lot of money as it allows you to schedule the pump to run whenever you want.
7. Sta-Rite P6E6VS4H-209L IntelliPro
Check Price at Amazon
Sta-Rite P6E6VS4H-209L IntelliPro
Specifications
- Pool type: In Ground
- Amperage: 16 amps
- Horsepower: 3 hp
- Noise: Near-silent operation – up to 45 decibels
- Speed settings: 8 programmable speed settings
- Speed range: 2700 to 3500 rpm
- TEFC Permanent Motor : Yes
- Warranty: 2-year
- Main highlights: Built-in diagnostics safeguard, integrated keypad, exclusive software and digital controls
This pump is without a doubt one of the best on the market. Even though it uses annual energy of up to 1,150 kWh, you will find that it can save up to 90% of energy per year. The reason for this is because the superior magnet motor uses the same technology found in hybrid automobiles. You will be able to choose between 8 programmable speed settings so it matches the pool’s requirements as soon as you install it. What stands out about this product is the fact that it has an enclosed fan-cooled motor. Therefore, it produces noise of up to 45 decibels. The motor has the ability to run cooler, quieter and it will last much longer as it’s enclosed.
You will be thoroughly pleased to know that this model has been crafted with a built-in diagnostics safeguard which means that you will know what is wrong with it without needing to second-guess. Also, by considering this model you will be pleased to know that you can add pool features without it having a negative effect on pump efficiency.
PROS
- Energy star certified
- Quiet operation
- Permanent magnet, totally enclosed fan cooled (TEFC) motor
- It helps you save up to 90% on energy costs
Verdict
The reason why we recommend this model is because it ensures a longer pool pump life. Without a doubt, this model can be considered as an investment rather than a meaningless purchase as it will maintain the same high efficiency throughout the years.
8. XtremepowerUS 75021 Pump
Check Price at Amazon
Specifications
- Pool type: In Ground
- Amperage: 15 amps
- Horsepower: 1.5 hp
- Compatibility: DE, sand, and cartridge filter
- Speed settings: 4 programmable speed settings
- Speed range: 750 to 3450 rpm
- TEFC Permanent Motor : Yes
- Warranty: 1-year
- Main highlights: LCD screen, self-contained 24-hour time clock, built-in timer
The 4 programmable speed settings make this model one of the best on the market. In addition to this, it also has a programmable timer which means that it will run at an optimal speed for as long as it needs to. This machine is suitable for pools that require a 1.5 HP pump. The power draws for each flow is as following, 750 RPM – 30-watts, 1500 RPM – 75-watts, 2500 RPM – 350-watts, and 3450 RPM – 890-watts. The LCD display will let you know the speed, time, and the exact settings it’s operating on.
Furthermore, this is one of the most practical pump as it’s compatible with DE, sand, and cartridge filter. You don’t have to worry about thorough maintenance as it has a clear cover. Hence, you will know when the basket needs to be cleaned. As well as, the drain plug will also help with cleaning. Additionally, this is not only safe but also one of the most efficient pumps on the market as it’s ETL certified.
PROS
- User-friendly design
- Energy Star Certified
- Quiet operation
- Suitable with a range of filters
- Easy maintenance
CONS
- You have to prime the pump before starting
Verdict
Without a doubt, this is another model that we recommend due to the fact that it’s versatile and practical. Even if you have a salt water pool, you will find that this model is also suitable for your needs.
Specifications
- Pool type: In Ground
- Amperage: 0.7~9.5 amps
- Horsepower: 1.5 hp
- Compatibility: DE, sand, and cartridge filter
- Speed settings: 3 speeds
- Speed range: 1000 to 3450 rpm
- TEFC Permanent Motor : Yes
- Warranty: Not given information
- Main highlights: 3 cleaning programs, LED indicators for speed, alarm indicators and error messages
The Harris In-Ground Pump is the pump you need if you want to save some money. In comparison to its above competitors, it is more affordable and its maintenance doesn’t cost as much as you might think. With a reinforced thermoplastic body and a 1.5 hp stainless steel motor, it claims to be one of the most durable pool pumps out there. Also, all its components are made of graphite and carborundum. This extend the pumps’ life. As compared to other similar units, this one provides quiet operation. It is not noisy and it doesn’t bother you at all while swimming or relaxing in the pool or spa. It comes with a control panel that can be used to set the desired program. There are three programs to choose from, such as regular mode, mode 1 and mode 2.
- Regular Mode Choose between Eco with 1500rpm, Clean with 2400rpm and Boost with 3250rpm
- Mode 1 A standard clean cycle takes about 16 hours
- Mode 2 A more effective clean cycle takes about 24 hours
As previously mentioned, all these settings can be made on the control panel that also features:
- LED indicators for speed They allow you to set the desired speed
- Alarm indicators and Error messages They provide information about the temperature, over and under voltage or freeze protection
PROS
- It meets and exceeds all CSA and ETL standards
- High quality materials
- It runs with minimal noise
- Great price
- Easy maintenance
Verdict
It might be not one of the most powerful pool pumps on the marketplace, but it still is a popular option to make. With a 1.5 hp stainless steel motor and a thermoplastic body, it is that durable pump that every pool and spa needs. Since it meets and exceeds all standards and requirements, we strongly consider that it is a great value for the money.
Now is the perfect time to change your faulty pump and invest in a more quality one. Finding the right variable speed pump could be a back-breaking task as the market is overflowing with a broad array of different models and versions of pumps. Or, perhaps it would work better a single speed pump. We also have a third version which is a double speed pump. What do you say? What is more tempting to you? In order to help you decide what to choose, we would like to present to you the basics of each type of pump.
Single speed pump
Highlights |
Drawbacks |
- it has been one of the most popular types for decades
- it operates at 3450 revolutions per minute (RPM)
- it runs at a single horsepower ranging from ¾ HP to 3 HP
- the most affordable type of pumps
- it doesn’t require day-to-day maintenance, but it will in time
|
- it is louder than the other 2 types of pumps
- since it has the highest operational costs of all those three types, it is not suitable for a swimming pool that is used daily
|
Double speed pump
Highlights |
Drawbacks |
- it changes its speed from fast to low and low to fast
- it runs with two different Hps
- energy-efficient – it contributes to operational cost savings
- it doesn’t produce noise when running at low speed
- very easy to install and operate
|
- more expensive than single-speed models
- it is loud when running at fast speed
- it is not recommended for residential pools. It works better in spas and jacuzzi
- it could be a bit complicated to fine tune flow rates
- most models lack controllers or timers – sometimes these additional features may be needed
|
Variable Speed Pump
Highlights |
Drawbacks |
- the most eco-friendly, energy-efficient pumps
- it uses less energy then the other types of pumps
- range speed – 600 -3450 RPM
- it works at full range of Hps
- it fines tune flow rate with ease
- the most quietest pump
|
- the most expensive type of pump
|
Important Factors to Take into Consideration
If you are reading this, then you probably need a variable speed pump. According to several swimming pool installers, these types of pumps are the right way to a well-maintained pool without having to deal with a loud operation, day-to-day maintenance or absurd energy consumption costs. As compared to the other two types of pumps, such as single-speed and two-speed pumps, this one is efficient, quiet and extremely inexpensive to run. In some cases, you can even save up to $1000 per month in electricity costs. Finding the right model for your needs could be quite complicated as there are too many models on the market and most of them are equipped with many features and settings hard to navigate. However, it is not impossible to find what you need, but there are some important factors to consider when making this kind of purchase.
Most Relevant Aspects |
More Detailed Information |
Best Choice |
Efficiency |
The variable speed pumps can be adjusted minutely, which means that they are more efficient than the other two types of pumps. It allows you to set the flow rate according to your swimming pool needs. Indeed, this is a good way to save some money. Also, it is very important to know that a variable speed pump is usually equipped with a powerful permanent magnet motor. For example, all our models are powered by a totally enclosed fan-cooled motor (TEFC) which make them use less electricity. |
All models |
Noise level |
As mentioned above, all variable speed pumps use permanent magnet motor. This is a major perk, especially due to the fact that this type of motor is extremely quiet and makes less noise than either single or dual speed pumps. The best part is that even with 3450 revolutions per minute, the pump is inaudible. |
Pentair 011018 IntelliFlo, Hayward SP3400VSP Ecostar, Hayward SP2303VSP Max-Flo |
Flow rate |
If you have any doubts about the flow rate of your pump or you don’t know exactly what it means, these lines are for you. Firstly, you should know that it represents the amount of water that it can process within a given standard period. Secondly, keep in mind that it strongly depends on the balance between pool size and the revolutions per minute of the pump. |
All models |
Plumbing |
Before making a purchase, take into account several factors, including the design of your pool plumbing. This way, you will benefit from an easy installation and it will save you headaches in the future regarding the day-to-day maintenance. Remember something! The larger pipe diameter, the most efficient the plumbing is. |
Pentair 011018 IntelliFlo, Hayward SP3400VSP Ecostar |
Programming options |
Most models come equipped with built-in programming options that make them more efficient than the other two types. With these programming options, you will be able to set them as you want. Plus, you shouldn’t worry anymore about switching speeds as this will change automatically. |
Pentair 011018 IntelliFlo, Hayward SP3400VSP Ecostar, Hayward SP2303VSP Max-Flo |
Horsepower |
As you probably know, the three-horsepower pumps are the most powerful out there. However, this doesn’t mean that they are the best or the most efficient. You may not need this type of pump even if your pipe could handle it. This could be a waste of energy and money. However, this also depends on the size of your swimming pool. |
Pentair 011018 IntelliFlo, Hayward SP2303VSP Max-Flo, Pentair 342001 SuperFlo |
Pool Pump Troubleshooting
If a pool pump doesn’t perform as it should, then something’s wrong. You may encounter many issues, but let’s take a look at the most common problems and see how you will be able to fix them.
-
The pump may be leaking
Take a quick look at the pump and see if it is damaged. If the water is leaking from it, then it could be damaged the shaft seal or the thread sealant. Or perhaps, you have problems with the impeller housing O-ring. Whether they are old and need to be replaced or something’s broken and needs to be fixed. According to several experts, it’s better to replace them with some new ones rather than fix them.
-
The motor doesn’t work anymore
If the motor doesn’t work anymore, check the electrical part. It could be frustrating to deal with a motor that won’t turn on. In this case, only an electrician can help you. If the lines work, there may be a heat issue. The vents around the motor should be cleaned in order to prevent overheating.
-
The pump doesn’t pull water
First of all, check out if the pump is clogged. Check the baskets and the skimmer as well. If they are damaged, the water cannot pass through the pump. Another factor to consider is the impeller. The baskets are fine, the skimmer as well, but what about the impeller? Is it clogged as well? If so, clean it by removing away all the debris.
-
Loud operation
If the pool pump is making noise, then the motor is probably damaged. Or perhaps, you have to replace the bearings of the motor. However, don’t worry as the bearings won’t cost you too much. More than that, if the pump is covered by a warranty, the manufacturer will replace the damaged parts.
Frequently Asked Questions
1How long does it last a variable speed pump?
Usually, the variable speed pumps last longer than the other two types of pumps, generally up to 10 years. Plus, there is a 1, 3-year warranty, depending on the model.
2How long should it run every day?
According to several experts, it is recommended to run your pool’s pump for at least 12 hours a day.
3What is the difference between an induction motor and a TEFC motor?
As you probably know, the induction motors are used in single or double-speed pumps while the other is used in variable speed pumps. The TEFC motor is the same motor used in electric cars and it is much quieter and more durable. Plus, it vibrates less and runs cooler.
1What rpm should I run my variable speed pool pump?
It’s quite difficult to answer this question. The speed you should run your pool pump, it strongly depends on the type of pump you choose to use. Of course, it also depends on the pool volume. At first, it is recommended to let it run at the maximum speed at least once a week. Every 6 o 8 hours, it should be running at maximum speed.
5How does a variable speed pool pump work?
You might think that a variable speed pump is one of the largest energy consumers. The truth is that the latest models are energy-efficient and doesn’t consume as much energy as you might think. Most pumps use magnets to spin the rotor. As compared to single pumps that need additional electricity to start working, the variable pumps work without additional electricity. They slow the water flow and decrease motor speed. This way, you will pay less on energy bills.
Best for Energy Efficiency
Pentair 011018 IntelliFlo
A variable speed pump will help you reduce energy costs in the long-term. It features a quiet operation while improving pool circulation. Pentair 011018 IntelliFlo is the best option in terms of energy-efficiency as it will significantly lower your energy bills. It is also extremely silent and easy to maintain. The pump is equipped with a powerful motor that delivers 3hp at speed of 450-3450 rpm. You will be able to choose from 8 programmable speed settings to ensure good operation. Also, there is a built-in timer that reinforces the idea of energy efficiency.
Best for Quiet Operation
Hayward SP3400VSP Ecostar
Hayward SP3400VSP Ecostar works great and it is self-priming. It is very easy to use and set up. The no-rib basket is a nice addition. Similar to Pentair 011018 IntelliFlo, it comes with a powerful 3 hp motor that delivers a speed of 600-3450 rpm. Furthermore, we all know how annoying is to hear all day long the noisy pool pump of your neighbors. With this in mind, we have tried to select pumps that operate silently. Hence, of all the above mentioned models, Hayward SP3400VSP Ecostar is the quietest models. Its totally enclosed fan cooled motor makes it operate in a silent manner.
Best for Money
Pentair 342001 SuperFlo
Also made by Pentair, Pentair 342001 SuperFlo is perfect if you’re on a budget. It provides great suction and it is easy-programmable. As compared to its above competitors, it has only 4 speeds to choose from. However, it still has other feature that makes it work incredibly well. Therefore, it comes equipped with a built-in timer and real-time 24-hour clock.
